1. Home
  2. Jewelry & Accessories
  3. Jewelry
  4. Rings
  5. Engagement Rings
  6. Gemstone Engagement Rings

Gemstone Engagement Rings

Shop Vintage Gemstone Engagement Rings

Sort By

Filter: 1,064 items

Sort By
Vintage GRS Certified 2.47 Carat Royal Blue Sapphire & Diamond Platinum Ring, Size 6 For Sale

Vintage GRS Certified 2.47 Carat Royal Blue Sapphire & Diamond Platinum Ring, Size 6

$9,780
Product ID: 16682188
Art Deco Colombian Emerald Engagement Ring in 18k Gold, Size 8 For Sale

Art Deco Colombian Emerald Engagement Ring in 18k Gold, Size 8

$5,060
Product ID: 16682221
Natural 2.48 Carat TW Colombian Emerald & Diamond Halo Ring in 18K Yellow Gold 2, Size 7 For Sale

Natural 2.48 Carat TW Colombian Emerald & Diamond Halo Ring in 18K Yellow Gold 2, Size 7

$7,880
Product ID: 16681957
GIA 1.25CT Pear Cut Fancy Green Yellow Diamond 18K Tri-Colored Gold Bypass Ring, Size 7.25 For Sale

GIA 1.25CT Pear Cut Fancy Green Yellow Diamond 18K Tri-Colored Gold Bypass Ring, Size 7.25

$28,750
Product ID: 16682154
Natural 3.76 Carat Colombian Emerald & Trillion Cut Diamond 3-Stone Ring in 18k, Size 7 For Sale

Natural 3.76 Carat Colombian Emerald & Trillion Cut Diamond 3-Stone Ring in 18k, Size 7

$44,200
Product ID: 16681943
Natural Unheated Padparadscha Sapphire Gemstone 1.00 Carats Set in Platinum Ring With 18k Rose Gold With 0.39 Carats Diamonds Size 6.5 For Sale

Natural Unheated Padparadscha Sapphire Gemstone 1.00 Carats Set in Platinum Ring With 18k Rose Gold With 0.39 Carats Diamonds Size 6.5

$9,331
Product ID: 22684323
0.73 Ct Emerald Cut Emerald & Emerald Cut Diamond Trilogy Ring Size 7 For Sale

0.73 Ct Emerald Cut Emerald & Emerald Cut Diamond Trilogy Ring Size 7

$2,500
Product ID: 22737683
1930s Art Deco Gia 2.59 Old European Cut Diamond Platinum Engagement Ring Size 7 For Sale

1930s Art Deco Gia 2.59 Old European Cut Diamond Platinum Engagement Ring Size 7

$35,000
Product ID: 22729639
1930s Art Deco Gia 2.01 Carat Old Mine Diamond Platinum Engagement Ring Size 6.25 For Sale

1930s Art Deco Gia 2.01 Carat Old Mine Diamond Platinum Engagement Ring Size 6.25

$21,000
Product ID: 22729626
Alexander Beverly Hills Egl 2.34ct Princess Cut Diamond 3-Stone Ring 18k Size 6.5 For Sale

Alexander Beverly Hills Egl 2.34ct Princess Cut Diamond 3-Stone Ring 18k Size 6.5

$16,900
Product ID: 22728909
Natural Paraiba Tourmaline Gemstone 1.29 carats in 14K White Gold with Diamonds Size 6.5 For Sale

Natural Paraiba Tourmaline Gemstone 1.29 carats in 14K White Gold with Diamonds Size 6.5

$10,267
Product ID: 22395666
1ct Aquamarine Ring with Earth Mined Diamond in Solid 14K White Gold EM 6.5x5.5mm For Sale

1ct Aquamarine Ring with Earth Mined Diamond in Solid 14K White Gold EM 6.5x5.5mm

$1,923
Product ID: 19026979
Untreated Color Change Alexandrite Stone 0.30 cts in Platinum Ring with Diamonds Size 6 For Sale

Untreated Color Change Alexandrite Stone 0.30 cts in Platinum Ring with Diamonds Size 6

$8,873
Product ID: 22395849
1.92 Carat Aquamarine Diamond White Gold Engagement Ring Size 7 For Sale

1.92 Carat Aquamarine Diamond White Gold Engagement Ring Size 7

$2,320
Product ID: 22737292
1930s Art Deco Gia 1.50 Carat Old Mine Diamond Platinum Engagement Ring Size 4.25 For Sale

1930s Art Deco Gia 1.50 Carat Old Mine Diamond Platinum Engagement Ring Size 4.25

$14,500
Product ID: 22729624
1930s Gia 1.50 Carat Old Mine Cut Diamond Platinum Filigree Engagement Ring Size 6 For Sale

1930s Gia 1.50 Carat Old Mine Cut Diamond Platinum Filigree Engagement Ring Size 6

$9,800
Product ID: 22729625
Antique 0.90ct Old European Cut Diamond Engagement Ring, 14kt Yellow Gold Size 6.75 For Sale
0.38ʺW

Antique 0.90ct Old European Cut Diamond Engagement Ring, 14kt Yellow Gold Size 6.75

$6,000
Product ID: 22700159
1.02 Ct Emerald & Round Brilliant Cut Diamond Trilogy Wedding Engagement Ring Us 7 For Sale

1.02 Ct Emerald & Round Brilliant Cut Diamond Trilogy Wedding Engagement Ring Us 7

$2,520
Product ID: 22704145
Red Star Ruby Stone 5.45 cts in 14K Yellow Gold Ring with Diamonds Size 6.25 For Sale

Red Star Ruby Stone 5.45 cts in 14K Yellow Gold Ring with Diamonds Size 6.25

$9,890
Product ID: 22395738
3 Stone London Topaz Ring with Natural Diamonds in Solid 14K Yellow Gold Round 3mm For Sale

3 Stone London Topaz Ring with Natural Diamonds in Solid 14K Yellow Gold Round 3mm

$873
Product ID: 19027429
Unheated Purple Pink Sapphire Stone 1.52 cts in Platinum Ring w Dia Size 6.5 For Sale

Unheated Purple Pink Sapphire Stone 1.52 cts in Platinum Ring w Dia Size 6.5

$9,828
Product ID: 22395801
Round Natural Gray Diamond Ring With Triangle Accents in 18k Rose Gold Size 7 For Sale

Round Natural Gray Diamond Ring With Triangle Accents in 18k Rose Gold Size 7

$6,790
Product ID: 22622527
Natural Unheated Burma Red Spinel Gemstone 1.56 Carats Set in Platinum Ring With 18k Yellow Gold With 0.30 Carats Diamonds Size 6.5 For Sale

Natural Unheated Burma Red Spinel Gemstone 1.56 Carats Set in Platinum Ring With 18k Yellow Gold With 0.30 Carats Diamonds Size 6.5

$12,074
Product ID: 22498221
14k Yellow Gold Gia 1.31ctw Diamond Engagement Ring, Ring Size 8 For Sale

14k Yellow Gold Gia 1.31ctw Diamond Engagement Ring, Ring Size 8

$2,995
Product ID: 22695236
Gia Certified 1.70ct Emerald Cut I Vs1 Diamond Engagement Ring White Gold Size 5.75 For Sale

Gia Certified 1.70ct Emerald Cut I Vs1 Diamond Engagement Ring White Gold Size 5.75

$20,250
Product ID: 22653014
Natural Unheated Padparadscha Sapphire Gemstone 1.61 Carats Set in Platinum Ring With 18k Rose Gold With 0.29 Carats Diamonds Size 6.5 For Sale

Natural Unheated Padparadscha Sapphire Gemstone 1.61 Carats Set in Platinum Ring With 18k Rose Gold With 0.29 Carats Diamonds Size 6.5

$13,905
Product ID: 22496669
1.43ctw Sapphire and Diamond Engagement Ring, 14k White Gold, Ring Size 6.5 For Sale
0.33ʺW

1.43ctw Sapphire and Diamond Engagement Ring, 14k White Gold, Ring Size 6.5

$1,295
Product ID: 22700074
Natural Diamond Stone 0.95 cts in 18K White Gold Ring with Diamonds / IGI Report Size 6.25 For Sale

Natural Diamond Stone 0.95 cts in 18K White Gold Ring with Diamonds / IGI Report Size 6.25

$12,633
Product ID: 22395521
Vintage 2.61 Carat European Cut M-N/Vs1 Diamond Art Deco Engagement Ring Size 7.75 For Sale

Vintage 2.61 Carat European Cut M-N/Vs1 Diamond Art Deco Engagement Ring Size 7.75

$27,180
Product ID: 22642529
Alexander Beverly Hills Gia 14.53ct No Heat Ceylon Sapphire & Diamonds Ring 18k Size 6.25 For Sale

Alexander Beverly Hills Gia 14.53ct No Heat Ceylon Sapphire & Diamonds Ring 18k Size 6.25

$33,000
Product ID: 22653789
Unheated Red Ruby Stone 3.10 cts in 18K Two Tone Ring with Diamonds Size 7.25 For Sale

Unheated Red Ruby Stone 3.10 cts in 18K Two Tone Ring with Diamonds Size 7.25

$17,454
Product ID: 22395806
1.30 Carat Oval Deep Blue Sapphire & Round Diamond 18k White Gold Ring Size 6.25 For Sale
0.37ʺW

1.30 Carat Oval Deep Blue Sapphire & Round Diamond 18k White Gold Ring Size 6.25

$3,060
Product ID: 22642531
Alexander Beverly Hills 8.20ct Oval Santa Maria Aquamarine and Diamond Ring 18k Size 6.5 For Sale

Alexander Beverly Hills 8.20ct Oval Santa Maria Aquamarine and Diamond Ring 18k Size 6.5

$16,700
Product ID: 22653786
Natural Unheated Sunrise Padparadscha Sapphire Gemstone 1.00 Carats Set in Platinum Ring With 18k Rose Gold With 0.35 Carats Diamonds Size 6.5 For Sale

Natural Unheated Sunrise Padparadscha Sapphire Gemstone 1.00 Carats Set in Platinum Ring With 18k Rose Gold With 0.35 Carats Diamonds Size 6.5

$11,618
Product ID: 22684316
Pear Cut Color Change Sapphire Ring in 18k Gold Size 7 For Sale

Pear Cut Color Change Sapphire Ring in 18k Gold Size 7

$4,890
Product ID: 22626384
Egl Certified 1.01 Carat Round F-G/Si3 Diamond Platinum Bypass Engagement Ring Size 6.5 For Sale

Egl Certified 1.01 Carat Round F-G/Si3 Diamond Platinum Bypass Engagement Ring Size 6.5

$10,360
Product ID: 22642523
Natural Green Tsavorite Gemstone 2.13 cts in 18K White Gold Ring with Diamonds Size 7 For Sale

Natural Green Tsavorite Gemstone 2.13 cts in 18K White Gold Ring with Diamonds Size 7

$11,618
Product ID: 22395563
Natural Blue Sapphire Gemstone 1.60 cts in 14KWG Ring with Diamonds Size 6.5 For Sale

Natural Blue Sapphire Gemstone 1.60 cts in 14KWG Ring with Diamonds Size 6.5

$11,755
Product ID: 22395843
1.35ctw Sapphire and Diamond Engagement Ring, 14k White Gold, Ring Size 5 For Sale

1.35ctw Sapphire and Diamond Engagement Ring, 14k White Gold, Ring Size 5

$1,195
Product ID: 22695228
Natural Red Ruby Gemstone 1.34 cts in Platinum Ring with Diamonds Size 6 For Sale

Natural Red Ruby Gemstone 1.34 cts in Platinum Ring with Diamonds Size 6

$13,952
Product ID: 22395722
Edwardian Diamond & 14k Yellow Gold Ring Size 6.5 For Sale

Edwardian Diamond & 14k Yellow Gold Ring Size 6.5

$700$780
Product ID: 14662789
0.33ctw Diamond Engagement Ring, Platinum, Ring Size 7.5 For Sale

0.33ctw Diamond Engagement Ring, Platinum, Ring Size 7.5

$895
Product ID: 22694041
Salt and Pepper Diamond Ring in 18k Gold Size 7 For Sale

Salt and Pepper Diamond Ring in 18k Gold Size 7

$2,870
Product ID: 22548413
Fancy Cut Black Diamond Ring With Natural Color Shift in 18k Gold Size 7 For Sale

Fancy Cut Black Diamond Ring With Natural Color Shift in 18k Gold Size 7

$2,350
Product ID: 22546364
Egl Certified 1.65 Carat Round & Princess Diamond Platinum Channel Set Ring Size 6.5 For Sale
0.22ʺW

Egl Certified 1.65 Carat Round & Princess Diamond Platinum Channel Set Ring Size 6.5

$12,160
Product ID: 22642525
Kite Cut Green Tanzanian Sapphire Engagement Ring in 18k Gold Size 7 For Sale

Kite Cut Green Tanzanian Sapphire Engagement Ring in 18k Gold Size 7

$11,980
Product ID: 22547960
Cushion Cut Salt and Pepper Diamond Ring With Baguette Accents in 18k White Gold Size 7 For Sale

Cushion Cut Salt and Pepper Diamond Ring With Baguette Accents in 18k White Gold Size 7

$3,200
Product ID: 22621885
Alexander Beverly Hills 1.07ctt Emerald Cut Aquamarine and Diamond Ring 18k Size 6.5 For Sale

Alexander Beverly Hills 1.07ctt Emerald Cut Aquamarine and Diamond Ring 18k Size 6.5

$1,750
Product ID: 22653012
Displaying page 13 of 23

Still on the hunt?

  Never miss new arrivals that match exactly what you're looking for!
Gemstone Engagement Rings

Shop Jade Tree Vintage Goods
Jade Tree Vintage Goods
shop now
Shop Jade Tree Vintage GoodsShop Jade Tree Vintage GoodsShop Jade Tree Vintage Goods
Shop Teatown Vintage
Teatown Vintage
shop now
Shop Teatown VintageShop Teatown VintageShop Teatown Vintage

View all

    Related Collections

    View All Related Collections